Published on:

Expert Tips for Negotiating a Settlement with an Insurance Company


As experienced personal injury attorneys, we understand that negotiating a fair settlement with an insurance company can be complex and intimidating. That’s why we’re providing expert tips to empower you during this critical process.

  1. Understand Your Claim’s Value

Before entering into negotiations, assess the total value of your claim, considering all medical expenses, lost wages, future medical needs, pain, suffering, and other damages. Having a clear picture of your claim’s worth is key to recognizing a fair settlement offer.

  1. Don’t Accept the First Offer

The first offer from an insurance company is often a ‘low-ball’ offer, intended to settle the claim quickly and cheaply. Politely decline and prepare to present your counteroffer.

  1. Counter with a Justified Amount

When countering the initial offer, propose a settlement amount higher than what you expect to receive. This gives room for negotiation. Ensure you can justify this amount with your evidence of damages.

  1. Provide Supporting Evidence

Present clear, organized evidence supporting your claim. This includes medical reports, photographs, witness statements, proof of income loss, and more. Strong evidence strengthens your negotiating position.

  1. Remain Patient and Persistent

Negotiations can be a lengthy process, and it’s essential to be patient and persistent. Don’t rush into accepting an offer that’s less than you deserve.

  1. Maintain a Professional Tone

Stay professional, calm, and courteous during all communications. A professional demeanor can improve the negotiation process.

  1. Consult a Personal Injury Attorney

Engaging a seasoned personal injury attorney can make all the difference. They bring expertise and negotiation skills, understanding the tactics insurance companies use and how to effectively counter them.

At our law firm, we strive to ensure our clients are equipped with the knowledge and resources they need to secure fair compensation. We’ve successfully negotiated numerous settlements with insurance companies, and we’re ready to support you in your personal injury claim.

Remember, the goal of the insurance company is to settle your claim for as little as possible. By contrast, our goal is to protect your rights and ensure you receive the full compensation you deserve. Don’t face this challenging process alone; we’re here to assist and guide you every step of the way.

Raving Fans
"I find Christopher Earley to be one of the most professional and compassionate attorneys I have ever met. After having a personal injury, what you need is expertise, experience, and especially compassion and kindness. All of these things define Christopher Earley. I highly recommend Christopher Earley and The Earley Law Group Injury Lawyers to anyone that needs a personal injury attorney!" Susan N.
"Great help with my case. Responses are fast and make me feel very well represented. This man is the guy to call." Hugh R.
"Chris helped me with an extremely difficult time in my life due to a car accident. Even after the settlement, he continued to advocate for me when I was receiving collections notices that were not valid. You can feel assured he will do a great job." Angela C.
Contact Information