Published on:

Determining Fault in Motorcycle Accidents

Determining Fault in Motorcycle Accidents

Motor vehicle accidents can be complex, with fault determination playing a crucial role in insurance claims and legal proceedings. In this article, we aim to show the standards used by insurers and the Board of Appeal in Massachusetts, especially in the context of motorcycle accidents, and discuss the process of appealing fault determinations.

Understanding Standards of Fault:

In Massachusetts, standards of fault are outlined in the Safe Driver Insurance Plan, which considers various scenarios to determine if an operator is more than 50% at fault. 

These scenarios include collisions with parked vehicles, rear-end collisions, out-of-lane collisions, failure to signal, and more. The presumptions raised by these scenarios are considered determinative unless the operator presents sufficient evidence to overcome them in a review or hearing.

Motorcycle Accidents and Fault Determination:

Contrary to a common assumption, fault in motorcycle accidents is not solely determined by investigating police officers. Auto insurance companies play a pivotal role in attributing fault, and disputes may lead to court involvement. Massachusetts no-fault car insurance statutes come into play for minor collisions, but serious injuries prompt insurers to thoroughly investigate fault, impacting potential damages and future insurance rates.

Defining At-Fault in Massachusetts

Being at fault in Massachusetts doesn’t mean bearing 100% responsibility. Instead, an operator is considered at fault if their actions contribute to more than 50% of the accident. The state recognizes situations of shared fault, following a system of modified comparative fault with a 51 percent bar. Total compensation may be reduced based on the percentage of fault attributed to the injured party.

Appealing Fault Determinations

If an insurer deems an individual more than 50% at fault, an appeal can be filed with the Board of Appeal at the Division of Insurance. The appeal process involves an informal hearing, and further appeals can be made to the local county court if necessary. It’s essential to recognize that insurance companies may not always prioritize the insured party’s interests, emphasizing the importance of a separate legal investigation to support a claim.


The outlined scenarios in the Safe Driver Insurance Plan offer a framework for determining fault, but the process involves a thorough examination of evidence and a potential appeal if disputing the insurer’s findings.

When delving into motorcycle accidents, it’s crucial to dispel the misconception that investigating police officers solely determine fault. Auto insurance companies, following Massachusetts no-fault car insurance statutes, play a pivotal role in attributing fault, especially in cases involving serious injuries. The impact of fault determination extends beyond immediate damages, affecting potential compensation and future insurance rates.

Understanding the Massachusetts definition of being at fault is equally essential, recognizing that it does not necessarily imply complete responsibility but rather signifies contributing over 50% to the accident. The modified comparative fault system allows for shared fault scenarios, impacting the total compensation based on the assigned percentage of blame.

Motorcycle accidents, known for their severity due to the inherent risks associated with riding, highlight the need for effective preventative measures. Statistics reveal that motorcycle fatalities accounted for 14% of all motor vehicle deaths in the United States, emphasizing the urgency in addressing motorcycle safety.

In the realm of traffic safety, motorcycle helmets emerge as a crucial factor in preventing head injuries and reducing motorcycle fatalities. Helmets have proven effective in preventing severe head trauma, a leading cause of death in motorcycle crashes. While sharing the road with other motor vehicles, motorcycle operators must prioritize safety by adhering to traffic laws, signaling appropriately, and being cautious at intersections, especially during left turns.

Recognizing the significance of preventing motorcycle crashes goes hand in hand with promoting responsible behaviors among all road users. Awareness campaigns and educational initiatives can contribute to creating a safer environment for motorcycle riders. Moreover, understanding the miles traveled aspect in relation to motorcycle deaths underscores the need for comprehensive strategies to address the unique challenges posed by motorcycles on the road.

In conclusion, the complex landscape of fault determination necessitates a nuanced understanding of the legal frameworks and avenues for appeal. Simultaneously, addressing the specific risks faced by motorcycle riders requires a collective effort towards preventive measures and a commitment to promoting traffic safety for all road users. 

As we share the road, prioritizing responsible behaviors and advocating for effective safety measures can significantly contribute to reducing the incidence of motorcycle crashes and, consequently, motorcycle fatalities.

 At Earley Law Group Injury Lawyers, we are here to assist you every step of the way. Our experienced team is dedicated to providing personalized legal support tailored to your unique situation.

Contact us today for a free consultation. Let us help you understand your rights, explore your legal options, and work towards the best possible outcome for your case. Don’t face the complexities of the legal system alone – trust Earley Law Group Injury Lawyers to advocate for you.

Raving Fans
"I find Christopher Earley to be one of the most professional and compassionate attorneys I have ever met. After having a personal injury, what you need is expertise, experience, and especially compassion and kindness. All of these things define Christopher Earley. I highly recommend Christopher Earley and The Earley Law Group Injury Lawyers to anyone that needs a personal injury attorney!" Susan N.
"Great help with my case. Responses are fast and make me feel very well represented. This man is the guy to call." Hugh R.
"Chris helped me with an extremely difficult time in my life due to a car accident. Even after the settlement, he continued to advocate for me when I was receiving collections notices that were not valid. You can feel assured he will do a great job." Angela C.
Contact Information